These delicious homemade Valentines suckers are such a fun treat to make! They are made with 5 simple ingredients and take less than 30 minutes from start to finish. They are the perfect Valentines treat to give to others or enjoy for yourself.

Homemade Sucker Recipe

With Valentine’s Day fast approaching, I thought it would be fun to make these cute suckers with my kids. My boys have so much fun making these, creating different color combinations and flavors and seeing how they’re going to turn out. This year, I had the thought that I would make these as Valentine’s treats for my kids to take to their school Valentine’s parties. I might regret that later, but it sounded like a good idea at the time.

These suckers take 5 simple ingredients and are done in less than 30 minutes. The flavor is unbeatable and they’re just cute! You’ll want to make sure to read the full post for all the details and tips and tricks I have learned while making these.

In addition, I have created some fun printable Valentines tags to go along with the suckers. My boys are very particular about the Valentine’s they give. They are not fans of the Valentine’s that say, “Be Mine” or anything to do with love. Maybe one day 😉 So, I made a few boy (and girl) approved tags and have added them to this post.

The Cowboys’ Rating: 10/10

Every time I make a new recipe, I have my family rate the recipe out of 10. By the time, these recipes make the blog, they’ve been tried and tested by some of my hardest tiny critics!

What Ingredients are in Homemade Suckers?

Water
White Sugar
Corn Syrup – I used light Karo corn syrup.
Hard Candy Flavoring Oil – There are many, many hard candy flavors and extracts to choose from, but I like to use hard candy flavoring oil. It’s stronger than extract and has a better flavor. The brand I used is called Dolce Flav Raspberry Flavor. I found it on Amazon, and you can find the link to it here. I have also used the brand LorAnn, and it is great to use as well.
Food Coloring – You can use regular food coloring or gel food coloring to add fun colors to your homemade suckers.

Tools You’ll Need

Measuring Cups
Liquid Measuring Cup
Saucepan
Heart Silicone Sucker Molds – You can use other candy molds, but these ones are my favorite. These make it really easy get the suckers out of the mold. You’ll want to get enough to make 20-25 suckers.
Sucker Sticks
Candy Thermometer (or regular digital food thermometer)
Metal Whisk
Plastic Wrap – I like to wrap the suckers individually in plastic wrap. I found that cutting the plastic wrap into little squares and then wrapping the suckers in the plastic wrap is actually the easiest way to do this.
Baking Sheet (optional). This isn’t absolutely necessary, but I like to put the molds on a baking sheet so that in case I dribble a little, it’s not all over my counter.

How to Make Homemade Valentines Suckers

On a baking sheet, lay out the candy molds and add sucker sticks to the molds. Press the sticks firmly down into the molds. Set aside.
In a saucepan, combine water, sugar and corn syrup.
Over medium high heat, bring to a boil.
Using a candy thermometer, monitor the temperature frequently. Cook to hard crack stage (300 degrees).
When it reaches 300 degrees, remove from heat and add candy flavoring and food coloring. Stir with a whisk for 1-2 minutes until well incorporated and smooth.
Pour into sucker molds. (You’ll want to do this as quick as possible because it hardens fast.)
Let the suckers sit for 10-15 minutes to harden fully.
Remove from molds.
Enjoy!

Printable Western Valentines

Here are a few fun Valentines to go with these homemade Valentine’s suckers. These are a free download that you can easily print out and attach to your homemade suckers with some string or ribbon. I hope you enjoy them!

Cattle tag valentines

Cattle Tag Valentines Download

western valentines

Western Valentines Download

Tips and Tricks

Here are a few things that I have learned that might be helpful!

Once the syrup mixture starts to boil, DO NOT stir it. When it first starts to boil, make sure to watch it carefully. If it looks like it is going to boil over, pick the saucepan up so that it’s not directly on the burner and let it settle. Once it settles (this only takes about 10-15 seconds) place it back on the burner and continue cooking.
This might get a little messy when pouring into the molds. If some oozes out or drizzles outside of the mold, it’s just fine. Once they are fully hardened, you can easily break off these unwanted pieces.
I like to wrap my suckers individually in plastic wrap. Cut small squares of plastic wrap and then wrap the suckers tightly and twist the plastic wrap around the sucker stick. It makes it easy to get off but also preserves the suckers. Store them in a cool dry place and they can last for months!
This one is important. To clean your saucepan afterwards, place some water in the saucepan and boil until the candy comes off. This will make things so much easier to clean up. If there is still some residue after boiling, simply run the saucepan under hot water and scrub lightly and the remaining residue will come off.
You can use other molds to mix things up! The silicone molds are my favorite. If you use other silicone molds, just make sure they are heat resistant.

Gluten Free Homemade Suckers

I’m so happy to share that this recipe is gluten free! I do always caution to double check your ingredients to make sure that the ingredients YOU use are gluten free.

Freshly Made on the Blog

Slow Cooker Beef Tips and Noodles

Sheet Pan Pizza

Skirt Steak Fajitas

Homemade Cinnamon Rolls